Was There Ever Nothing?

A thought journey on the beginning of time and the origin of the universe

Have you ever tried to think about the beginning—not just a long time ago, but the very first moment? Or even more fundamentally: whether there was ever a first moment at all?

One common idea is this: perhaps, at the very beginning, there was Absolutely Nothing.

Not empty space. Not darkness. Not even time. Nothing at all.

That idea seems simple—but when you try to think it through carefully, it becomes surprisingly difficult to make sense of.

---

Let's start with an analogy.

Imagine a large, sealed room: no doors, no windows, no air, no particles, no light. For intuition, we can call it "empty." But keep in mind, this room is still something; it has structure and space. True Absolutely Nothing would have no space, no structure, no possibility of anything existing at all. Still, this analogy helps us reason about the problem.

Now, suppose your goal is to get something into this room.

But there's a rule: you cannot use anything from outside the room.

Here's the dilemma: you have to produce something from what's inside the room. And what's inside the room? Absolutely Nothing.

---

You might think: "Well, maybe given enough time, something will just appear."

But this raises a fundamental problem. Time, by itself, does not introduce change. Things happen over time—but only if there is something already in existence to cause that change.

If you leave cookie dough on a counter for fifteen minutes, it doesn't bake. Not because the time is too short, but because there is nothing in the environment to make it bake. Likewise, if our sealed room contains Absolutely Nothing, then simply waiting—even for eons—cannot create anything. There is nothing to act, nothing to produce, nothing to spark a change.

---

Someone might object: "Quantum physics says particles can appear spontaneously."

That is true—but only within a physical system with laws, fields, and energy. Even the smallest quantum fluctuation requires a structured vacuum. It does not arise from Absolutely Nothing. In other words, the kind of "nothing" that quantum particles need is already a kind of "something."

So if we truly consider Absolutely Nothing—no space, no time, no energy, no laws—then the question becomes: how could anything ever exist?

---

Here's the key insight:

If there ever were Absolutely Nothing, it would still exist. Nothing can come from Absolutely Nothing. Yet something exists. You exist. The universe exists. Therefore, Absolutely Nothing never existed.

This suggests that there was always Something in existence. Not necessarily the universe as we know it, but some form of reality that cannot depend on anything else. Some eternal, self-sufficient Something.

And that leads us to the next question: what was this Something? Was it a single Something, or many? What properties did it have that allowed existence to unfold as it has?

To explore these questions, let's move on to Part 2: Something.

Back to Common Atheist Myths list